Feature Compliance Strategy
Sixteen Consent Orders Were Terminated. Don't Archive the Obligation Map.
The CFPB terminated 16 pending orders in FY2026 and waived redress allegations at Navy Federal. Build the closeout file before leadership declares victory.
Table of Contents
- The CFPB’s Semi-Annual Report to Congress, released October 27, 2026, reports 16 pending final orders terminated and one new action initiated for January through June 2026.
- Navy Federal is the outlier. The Bureau terminated its order July 1, 2025, waived alleged non-compliance, and left roughly $80 million in redress uncollected. The $15 million penalty was already paid.
- Termination closes the reporting obligation, not the root cause. Sixteen institutions are about to find out whether their control environment was ever the point, or whether the order was.
The victory memo writes itself. That’s the problem
Somewhere right now a general counsel is drafting a paragraph that begins “the Bureau has terminated its consent order, confirming the bank’s remediation.” It will go to the audit committee. The reporting calendar will be cleared, the dedicated inbox will be deprecated, and the monthly obligation tracker will be moved to an archive folder with a name like CFPB_2024_CLOSED.
Then a different examiner — not the one who wrote the order, not even the same agency — will sample the same process in eighteen months and find the control that existed to satisfy paragraph 41 has quietly degraded, because nothing was measuring it anymore.
The CFPB’s own report describes its reasoning in one sentence: the orders were terminated because “only burdensome administrative obligations remained, imposing unnecessary costs and requiring unwarranted oversight by the Bureau.” That is a statement about the Bureau’s workload. It is not a statement that your process is now safe.
What the numbers say
Table 1 of the report, on page 21, is three rows:
| Disposition | Count |
|---|---|
| Dismissed or withdrew as plaintiff | 1 |
| Terminated a pending order | 16 |
| Initiated | 1 |
The report also says the Bureau closed approximately 40 percent of pending investigations over the period, in line with narrowed priorities: servicemembers and veterans, mortgage matters, FCRA and Regulation V data furnishing, FDCPA and Regulation F collection, fraudulent overcharges, and inadequate data-security controls causing actual consumer loss.
Each terminated order gets its own entry in Section 4.3, with the order number and the paragraph the termination was executed under. Citibank (2023-CFPB-0013) came off October 16, 2025 after a $24.5 million penalty. Apple (2024-CFPB-0012) came off September 22, 2025 after $25 million. U.S. Bank’s two orders came off in August and September 2025 after $37.5 million and $15 million respectively.
And then there is Navy Federal (2024-CFPB-0014), terminated July 1, 2025. The report is unusually blunt about it. The order concerned authorize-positive, settle-negative overdraft fees. Navy Federal disclosed the fees three separate times, customers had to opt in, and the Bureau’s case rested on a 2022 UDAAP guidance that then-Acting Director Vought withdrew in May 2025. Navy Federal paid the $15 million penalty and did not pay any of the approximately $80 million in redress, which the report notes would have come from members’ pockets.
Read that again as a risk professional. An adverse outcome, a headline penalty, a remediation budget, and eighteen months later roughly four-fifths of the economic exposure evaporates for reasons that have nothing to do with the underlying facts.
If your board learned about your order from a press release, it learned the wrong lesson. The lesson is that order terms are political and the conduct is durable.
The distinction that matters
Two very different things live inside every consent order: completed remedial obligations and continuing restrictions. The first is finished work. The second is a standing promise the institution made to a regulator.
The report’s own framing depends on that split — it notes that in all but one instance, entities had paid required redress and civil penalty, so only administrative obligations remained. Sheppard Mullin’s analysis from July 2025 draws the practitioner conclusion directly: keep treating terminated orders “as a roadmap for compliance expectations,” and proactively audit similar practices.
Consumer Finance Monitor adds the line that should be stamped on the closure memo: terminating an order “does not mean the original conduct was lawful or consumers unharmed.”
So the closeout question is not “what can we stop doing.” It is “which of these obligations were load-bearing, and what measures them now that the order doesn’t.”
The closeout file, item by item
Build it before the reporting calendar clears. Eight items, each with a named owner and a home.
1. Obligation disposition table. Every numbered obligation in the order, one row each, dispositioned as satisfied and closed, satisfied and retained, or extinguished by termination. The third column is where the argument happens, so it needs a reason and a signature, not a checkmark. If a retained item has no control owner, it is not retained — it’s aspirational.
2. Final validation report per remediation. The testing that proved each fix worked, its sample, its exception rate, and who signed. This is the artifact that answers “how do you know it held” in a later exam. Where the validation was thin — a walkthrough rather than a sample — mark it, because a thin validation is exactly where the control will fail next.
3. Root-cause statement, one page. What caused the finding, stated in process terms rather than conduct terms. “Overdraft fee logic applied to APSN transactions before the disclosure was updated” survives leadership change; “the Bureau’s theory was overreach” does not.
4. Retained-control register. For each item worth keeping: control ID, owner, frequency, test procedure, and the specific finding it addresses. This is the document that replaces the order. Two fields make it real — a test procedure someone outside the owner can run, and a data source the owner cannot edit.
5. Repeat-finding watchlist. Any conduct previously cited by any regulator, ever. Fay Servicing’s 2024 order was itself about violations of a 2017 order on the same subject. Repeat findings convert a closed issue into an open one fast, and no examiner treats “the order was terminated” as a defense to a repeat.
6. The last two reporting cycles. Even where the reporting duty is extinguished, two finished cycles show the metric was stable at closure rather than improving into the deadline. If the final cycle was the best one, say why.
7. Dependency map. Every downstream process that consumed the order: the monthly board pack, the KRI set, the vendor contract clause that referenced it, the audit plan line item, the training module. Each needs an explicit decision — keep, re-point, or retire — or it will silently rot. The issue management framework covers how to close an item without orphaning the controls around it, and the order response anatomy is the mirror image — the same artifacts, read forward instead of closed out.
8. Signed closure memo. Which obligations are extinguished, which are kept voluntarily, the reason for each retention, the residual risk statement, and the date the first post-closure test runs. One page. Signed by the control owner and the second line, not just compliance.
Three tests you keep running
Some controls are worth keeping permanently, and they are almost always the cheap ones.
The metric that tracked the violation. If the order was about APSN fee incidence, fee-reversal rates, or denial reasons, that metric keeps reporting quarterly. Not monthly with a board slide — quarterly to the risk committee is enough, and it costs one query. The failure mode is that the dashboard gets retired with the order because it was labeled as order reporting rather than risk reporting. Label it by risk.
The sample that catches regression. Once a year, pull 25 files and check the specific condition the order addressed. Twenty-five is a starter number, not a benchmark: calibrate it against your exception rate over the first two cycles, and if you find nothing twice, ask whether the sample is reaching the right population rather than concluding the control is perfect.
The change-trigger review. Any system, vendor, or process change touching the remediated area gets a documented review against the original finding. This is the control that would have caught the second failure at most institutions, and it is also the one that dies first because it has no visible output until something goes wrong.
Where the owner argument happens
Closure memos get stuck on item one, column three. Legal wants everything extinguished; the business wants the retained register cut to three lines; audit wants all of it retained because retained is free.
A workable split, as a starting position: extinguish everything the order’s termination expressly releases, retain anything that addresses a repeat-finding risk or a live examiner commitment, and route the middle to the risk committee with the residual risk statement attached. Then have the second line sign the retained register alongside the owner. Unowned retention is the same as no retention, and the signature is what makes the ownership claim auditable.
One more discipline: run the closeout file past internal audit before the ink dries, not after. An auditor’s objection logged in the file is worth more than a clean file discovered to be wrong at the next exam.
So what
Sixteen terminated orders is not sixteen clean bills of health. It is sixteen institutions whose reporting duty just disappeared while their root causes did not, and at least one of them — Navy Federal — lost the economic pressure that usually forces the fix.
The first post-closure test is the whole ballgame. Schedule it before the memo is signed, put a date and an owner on it, and hold it. Our Issues Management Tracker & Template has the disposition, retention, and validation fields to run the closeout without building a spreadsheet from scratch.
FAQ
How many CFPB consent orders were terminated in FY2026?
Sixteen pending final orders were terminated between July 1, 2025 and June 30, 2026, per Table 1 of the CFPB’s Semi-Annual Report to Congress released October 27, 2026. The same table shows one action dismissed or withdrawn and one new action initiated.
What happened with the Navy Federal consent order?
The CFPB terminated the November 7, 2024 order on July 1, 2025 and waived any alleged non-compliance. Navy Federal had paid the full $15 million penalty but none of the roughly $80 million in redress, according to the report, which described the original order as resting on a withdrawn 2022 UDAAP guidance.
Does termination mean the underlying conduct was lawful?
No. The report attributes terminations to remaining obligations being merely administrative. Sheppard Mullin’s July 2025 analysis notes that terminations generally reflect completed monetary and conduct obligations rather than a changed view of the violations. The conduct, and the examiner interest in it, remain.
What belongs in a closeout file?
The dispositioned obligation map, validation reports, root-cause statement, retained-control register with owners and test procedures, the repeat-finding watchlist, the last two reporting cycles, a dependency map for downstream processes, and a signed closure memo naming the first post-closure test date.
Which controls should survive termination?
Anything addressing the original root cause, and especially anything previously cited. Fay Servicing’s 2024 order concerned violations of a 2017 order on the same subject. Repeat findings are what turn a terminated order back into an open issue.
◆ Need the working template?
Start with the source guide.
These answer-first guides summarize the required fields, evidence, and implementation steps behind the templates practitioners search for.
◆ Related template
Issues Management Tracker & Template
End-to-end issues tracking and remediation management for risk and compliance teams.
◆ Immaterial Findings · Weekly
Sharp risk & compliance insights. No fluff.
◆ FAQ
Frequently asked questions.
How many CFPB consent orders were terminated in FY2026?
What happened with the Navy Federal consent order?
Does termination mean the underlying conduct was lawful?
What should a closeout file contain?
Which controls should survive termination?
Author
Rebecca Leung
Rebecca Leung has 8+ years of risk and compliance experience across first and second line roles at commercial banks, asset managers, and fintechs. Former management consultant advising financial institutions on risk strategy. Founder of RiskTemplates.
◆ Related framework
Issues Management Tracker & Template
End-to-end issues tracking and remediation management for risk and compliance teams.
◆ Keep reading
Related posts.
Compliance Strategy
Third-Party Risk Board Metrics That Survive a Follow-Up Question
Five third-party risk board reporting metrics with definitions, paired evidence, and gaming vectors — built for a board that asks who signed.
Nov 16, 2026
Compliance Strategy
The Fed Is Restructuring How It Supervises Banks. What Bowman's Five-Region Overhaul Means for Community Banks and Their Exams.
Federal Reserve Vice Chair for Supervision Michelle Bowman announced a five-region supervision restructuring, alongside the Community Bank Leverage Ratio cut to 8% that took effect July 1. Here's what changes, what stays the same, and what community bank compliance teams should actually do.
Oct 13, 2026
Compliance Strategy
The OCC Just Made Recovery Planning Optional for $100 Billion Banks. Here's What Still Exists Under Safety and Soundness.
On May 1, 2026, the OCC's Appendix E recovery planning guidelines were officially gone for $100B+ banks. Comptroller Gould called them 'prescriptive' and 'conjectural.' But safety and soundness authority doesn't rescind. Here's what large-bank operational risk teams actually need to maintain — and what they can safely restructure.
Oct 11, 2026